Sotheby's International Realty® Listing
Listing hero image
236 Bay Walk
Fire Island Pines, New York, 11782
United States

236 Bay Walk
Fire Island Pines, New York, 11782 United States

  • Joshua Judge
  • Lily Christensen
Gallery media video
Listing image

236 Bay Walk

Welcome to 236 Bay Walk, located in the heart of Fire Island Pines. Massive scale and stunning water views abound at this historic estate, which rests on the largest double lot in The Pines.

Upon entering through the newly constructed cedar gatehouse, one is immediately greeted by a serene landscape featuring blossoming cherry trees, Japanese maples, mature bamboo, and a stocked koi pond with budding water lilies. At the end of the walkway, you'll find the giant pool, hot tub, and, of course, the home itself. With eight potential bedroom suites split between two separate wings of the home, the layout provides the flexibility and space to entertain on the largest scale, while maintaining privacy and tranquility.

The double height great room gives you and your guests unique drama, scale and the perfect position to enjoy the stunning sunsets over the Great South Bay. The chef's kitchen boasts two 36” Sub-Zero refrigerators, double dishwashers, ample storage, a beautifully furnished breakfast area, and an adjacent staff room with en-suite bathroom.

Each room is beautifully decorated as the home is offered fully furnished and in turn-key condition. The multi-year restoration of the estate was just completed, and the new owner can take possession and start enjoying the home immediately.

236 Bay Walk is as rich with history as The Pines itself. Once the home of the great composer Jerry Herman, 'Hello Dolly' is believed to have been written within these walls. Each year, this estate has been the backdrop of legendary events such as The Fire Island Dance Festival, IndepenDANCE, as well as hosting fundraisers with Cher and many more. The opportunity to celebrate The Pines at this level with such ease is rarely offered.

Listing image

Amenities & Features

  • Listing Details
    • Property ID
    • MLS#
    • Property type
      Single Family Homes
    • Marketed By
      Sotheby's International Realty - Downtown Manhattan Brokerage
    • Status
    • Listing Price
    • County
      Long Island
  • Utilities & Building
    • Financial
      Monthly Taxes: $1,359
    • Style
    • cooling
      Central Air Conditioning
  • Interior
    • Amenities
      Balcony, Deck, Pool, Spa / Hot Tub, Gardens, Hardwood Flooring, Terrace / Outdoor Space, Washer Included, Dryer Included
    • Full Bathrooms
    • Partial Bathrooms
    • Bedrooms
  • Additional Features
    • Features
      Water View

Marketed By

In the News

Monday, May 31, 2021

Cottages & Gardens, "Broadway Legend Jerry Herman’s Former Fire Island Pines Home Lists for $3.2M"

Cottages & Gardens