Sotheby's International Realty® Listing
Listing hero image
    34 High Street
    Sag Harbor, New York, 11963
    United States
    34 High Street Sag Harbor, New York, 11963 United States
    Save

    34 High Street
    Sag Harbor, New York, 11963 United States

    • Lawrence Ingolia
    • Jonathan Smith
    Gallery media video
    Listing image

    Property details

    • Property type

      Single Family Homes

    • Status

      Available

    • Year Built

      1900

    • property taxes

      $13,428/Year

    Sag Harbor Entertainers' Dream

    Freshly designed and newly renovated, this serene and spacious classic village luxury home, perched charmingly atop High Street on a 0.18+/- acre property in the heart of Sag Harbor's historic district, is the turn-key dream you've been waiting for. Flooded with natural light and tucked behind magnolia trees and year-round hedges, the designer interiors of this 3,200+/- sq. ft. 5 bedroom/5 bath house are finished with crisp white walls, period moldings and joinery, and recently refinished oak flooring. The updated floor plan, both an homage to a storied past and perfectly suited to today's lifestyles, flows effortlessly through double-width French doors from the dedicated entrance hall, formal living room, intimate dining room, to the parlor with fireplace and sophisticated chef's kitchen with designer appliances and additional glass-walled informal dining area, which was formerly a greenhouse. There is a large primary suite with a sitting area and sumptuous Carrara marble bathroom, as well as another large bedroom, walk-in closet, and spa bathroom on the second floor. An additional three bedrooms with a sky-lit marble bathroom are located on the third floor. Outside, overlooking a lovely grassy yard, soft-white pebbled paths, a private outdoor cedar shower, and a blue stone patio, an extensive deck, enshrouded in perennial flowers and featuring a built-in stainless-steel Viking grill, provides a fabulous outdoor entertaining area for balmy summer evenings. Finally, one of the truly unique - and rare for the village - property highlights is 'Le Rose de 34 Bis,' an enchanting one-story fully-renovated cottage space covered in roses and complete with full marble bath, loft and storage space for bikes, surfboards and beach chairs. Perfect for a home executive office or creative studio. Less than half a mile to Main Street, the American Hotel, the iconic cinema, legendary Havens Beach, and the Yacht Club, as well as the secret path to Sag Harbor's award-winning schools, this home is truly an American beauty and move-in ready for summer 2022.
    Local Expertise
    Get market insights from our local offices in the area. Find local offices

    about Sag Harbor

    Sag Harbor is approximately 100 miles from New York City, easily accessible by luxury bus liner, the Long Island Railroad and Expressway and Connecticut ferries. The historic village offers magnificent Sag Harbor real estate, many fine restaurants and boutiques and is home to the Bay Street Theatre, the legendary American Hotel, the Sag Harbor Whaling Museum and the first Customs House in the United States. The large boat basin harbors a variety of yachts and sailboats serviced by the Sag Harbor Yacht Club and the Breakwater Yacht Club, and hosts weekly sailboat races in season.

    Amenities & Features

    • Listing Details
      • Property ID
        4L25J3
      • MLS#
        888185
      • Property type
        Single Family Homes
      • Marketed By
        Sotheby's International Realty - Southampton Brokerage
      • Status
        Available
      • Listing Price
        $4,200,000
      • County
        New York County
      • School District
        Sag Harbor Union Free
    • Utilities & Building
      • Year Built
        1900
      • property taxes
        $13,428/Year
      • Lot Size Unit
        Acre(s)
      • Lot Size
        0.18
    • Interior
      • Amenities
        Deck, Hardwood Flooring, Washer Included, Dryer Included, 1 Fireplace
      • Full Bathrooms
        5
      • Bedrooms
        5